5 DCU moves that exposed James Gunn before Skydance pulled the plug

"Supergirl" New York Premiere - Source: Getty
"Supergirl" New York Premiere - Source: Getty

Peter Safran and James Gunn's exit from DC Studios this week has shocked comic book fans. Apart from Supergirl, their DCU projects were both critically acclaimed and commercially successful. Regardless of what Reddit and X (formerly Twitter) users claim, Gunn's DC projects, with the exception of Supergirl, were successful.

While he hasn't left DC Studios altogether, it looks like the filmmaker's days in that studio might be numbered. However, despite that, James Gunn did commit some moves during his tenure as the co-CEO of DC Studios that culminated in this week's exit.


Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion. Please be advised.

What were the five moves that James Gunn made that might have led to his and Peter Safran's exit?

Here are the five moves that I believe were mistakes on James Gunn's part:

Prioritizing niche projects

James Gunn made his mark in the wider comic book genre in 2014 with Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 1. The Guardians were a very niche superhero team before the first movie's release. Gunn brought his love for niche characters to DC. What drew fans' ire was DC's greenlighting of The People v. Gorilla Grodd, a show headlined by Skyler Gisondo's Jimmy Olsen.

This show was greenlit while Supergirl was underperforming and before Lanterns was released. Moreover, fans were even angrier that the DCU Batman has not been cast yet. Although the project was announced in 2023, The Brave and the Bold script might not be finished yet.

Gunn revealed last week that the casting for Batman would begin "soon", so the script might be at the finishing stage. But Gunn has not confirmed if the script is complete. The status of other projects announced in 2023, such as Paradise Lost, The Authority, and Waller, is similarly unclear.

Randomly greenlighting projects

The Clayface poster | Image Via: Instagram/@clayfacemovie
The Clayface poster | Image Via: Instagram/@clayfacemovie

James Gunn had announced a total of ten projects for the first phase of the DCU, which was called Chapter 1: Gods and Monsters. Here were all the projects that were announced initially:

  1. Superman: Legacy – Later released as Superman
  2. The Authority – Scrapped
  3. Creature Commandos – Season 1 streamed between December 2024 and January 2025. Season 2 in production
  4. The Brave and the Bold – In development
  5. Waller – No longer in active development
  6. Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow - Released as Supergirl
  7. Lanterns – Season 1 concluded last month. Season 2 rumored to be in development
  8. Swamp Thing – In development
  9. Booster Gold – Unconfirmed
  10. Paradise Lost ­– No longer in active development

Of these ten announced projects, only Superman, Creature Commandos Season 1, Supergirl, and Lanterns made it to the screen. The remaining six projects are still in development or have been cancelled or put on hold. Instead of focusing on these projects, DC Studios greenlit unplanned projects like Clayface (which, to be fair, is profitable) and The People v. Gorilla Grodd.

No Trinity

The DC Trinity in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice | Image Via: YouTube/Warner Bros.
The DC Trinity in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice | Image Via: YouTube/Warner Bros.

Fans have accused James Gunn of only green-lighting projects that suit his tastes. While DC is working on a solo Wonder Woman project and The Brave and the Bold script, neither is finished. Meanwhile, rumors suggest that Adria Arjona might be playing Wonder Woman in Man of Tomorrow. But this casting hasn't been confirmed yet.

This lack of development on Batman and Wonder Woman projects is one thing that soured fans on Gunn.

Timeline confusion

The DCU continuity | Image Via: Threads/jamesgunn
The DCU continuity | Image Via: Threads/jamesgunn

Last year, Gunn said that the DCU continuity was simple: it would follow the release plan. That meant Superman was set after Creature Commandos Season 1. However, this rule is no longer applicable, as The Suicide Squad and Peacemaker Season 1 were also made canon to the DCU with some changes. A fan put forth a DCU timeline that made sense.

James Gunn gave his stamp of approval to this fan-made timeline, saying, "Timelines give me anxiety but I think this is pretty good." These words stand in stark contrast to the MCU's approach, as that studio regularly updates its continuity.

Gunn was never comfortable with the executive role

The Superman director and his co-CEO, Peter Safran, released a joint statement after the news of their exit made its way online. However, Gunn released a more personal statement on his Instagram handle.

James Gunn described the filming of Superman, Peacemaker Season 2, and Man of Tomorrow as among the best times of his life, but he also revealed that he found the corporate side of his role "trying":

“What only the closest people to me have known over the past four years is my time at DC Studios has been trying, to say the least. I dislike the at-times corporate nature of the job (thanks to Peter for taking the brunt of that). I’m always a very hard worker, but as a filmmaker I would at least get to take short breaks to unwind, and I’ve stolen even that time from both myself and my loved ones over the past four years”

It is clear that the filmmaker's heart lies in directing movies rather than in being a CEO. Based on this statement, it seems that Gunn is more than happy to serve as a creative rather than as an executive.


What other mistakes do you think Gunn committed? Let us know.

Love movies? Try our Box Office Game and Movie Grid Game to test your film knowledge and have some fun!

Quick Links

Edited by Ravikumar N