74 year old man with throat cancer used AI generated avatar to represent himself in court in March 2025, leaving judge baffled

Empty Courtroom - Source: Getty
74-year-old man’s AI lawyer stuns judge during court appearance - Source: Getty

AI is replacing humans even in places for justice. A self-described entrepreneur and pro se litigant, Jerome Dewald, left a panel of New York appellate judges baffled in March 2025 when the video he submitted to support his employment appeal turned out to feature a man who does not exist. The clip, filmed by court cameras and shared on X by the account Sayitpop, shows Dewald seated with his legs crossed as Justice Sallie Manzanet-Daniels of the Appellate Division’s First Judicial Department stops the playback and asks:

“Ok, hold on. Is that counsel for the case?”

Dewald, 74, was representing himself. He answered from his seat:

“I generated that. That is not a real person.”

The court had allowed him to play a prerecorded video alongside his argument, but had not been told it starred an artificial avatar.

The judge paused before responding and then said that it would have been helpful to know that information when the application was submitted and pointed out that Dewald had not disclosed it earlier. She then asked for the video feed to be turned off and stated that she didn't appreciate being misled.

After the video was shut down, Dewald continued presenting his argument in person while reading from his phone.

Continue reading more about the story.


New York court clip: The AI avatar lasted one line before the panel cut it

The figure on screen was a younger man in a blue collared shirt and a beige sweater. He began:

"May it please the court, I come here today a humble pro se before a panel of five distinguished justices.”

The judges looked at one another. Manzanet-Daniels noted that Dewald had appeared before the court previously and had spent more than 30 minutes talking to staff in her clerk’s office, the Daily Mail reported. She also raised the prospect that he was promoting his business:

“You are not going to use this courtroom as a launch for your business, sir.”

Why did Jerome Dewald use an AI avatar?

Dewald told The Register that speaking at length is difficult for him because of throat cancer about 25 years earlier. He wanted a replica of himself, but the renders failed, so he used a stock avatar from Tavus that he called Jim. He is behind Pro Se Pro, a legal tech startup, The Verge reported. In a letter to the judges, he wrote,

“My intent was never to deceive but rather to present my arguments in the most efficient manner possible. However, I recognize that proper disclosure and transparency must always take precedence.”

He later told the Associated Press that the court reacted strongly to the situation and harshly criticized him over the issue.


Follow Soap Central for more updates on entertainment.

Love movies? Try our Box Office Game and Movie Grid Game to test your film knowledge and have some fun!

Edited by Rajarshi Deb