“The less we ask her things, the better”: Internet reacts as JoJo Siwa says she doesn’t “have to be gay to be a gay icon”

2026 Dancers Against Cancer
JoJo Siwa says she doesn’t “have to be gay to be a gay icon” - Source: Getty

JoJo Siwa has recently sparked online discussion after publicly saying she need not be gay to qualify as a gay icon, while reaffirming that she herself does not identify as straight. The singer shared these comments while appearing on The Viall Files podcast, where she was questioned about whether she continued to view herself as an LGBTQ+ community icon. A user wrote:

“The less we ask her things, the better.”

Siwa, who is presently dating a man, said her sexuality should not be determined solely by the gender of her current romantic partner. She likewise described herself as pansexual in the discussion, recalling an occasion when she noticed a pansexual pride flag.

Her remarks sparked responses throughout social media, as some users challenged her grasp of the term “gay icon” while others considered the broader discussion around her public persona.


What did JoJo Siwa say about being a gay icon?

On her visit to The Viall Files, JoJo Siwa addressed whether she continued to consider herself an icon within the queer community. Siwa said:

“First of all, you don’t have to be gay to be a gay icon … I’m in a relationship with a man. I’m not straight by any means. We were just in the E! News building, and I walked past a pansexual flag, and I literally looked at it, I was like, ‘H*ll yeah, that's me!’”

Her comments arose as she spoke about her identity while seeing a man, clarifying that being in a relationship perceived as heterosexual doesn't mean she identifies as straight.

Siwa's comments likewise refocused attention on discussions about her sexuality and public persona, especially following her earlier announcement that she was a lesbian.


Why has JoJo Siwa faced backlash over her sexuality and gay comments?

JoJo Siwa's recent remarks follow years of public conversation regarding her identity and her position in the LGBTQ+ community at large.

The former Dance Moms star openly came out in 2021, posting a photo of herself in a T-shirt reading “Best Gay Cousin Ever.” Later, she became an influential figure for younger LGBTQ+ audiences.

In 2024, she drew attention after labeling her musical direction “gay pop” and stating that she hoped to bring the genre back. In an interview with Billboard, Siwa spoke about her desire to develop a music genre, which she dubbed gay pop.

The comments faced widespread online mockery, with critics noting that queer artists had made and popularised the genre long before Siwa’s own public announcement.

Artists like Tegan and Sara and Charli XCX also drew attention to the debate with reactions on their social media accounts.

JoJo Siwa subsequently explained that she never meant to suggest she created gay pop music. Instead, she said she hoped to raise more awareness about the genre and its history. She also said she wanted the "CEO" or "CMO" role, rather than being its creator or president.


Why did JoJo Siwa's relationship with a man spark controversy?

The public discussion surrounding Siwa's identity gained renewed prominence in 2025 after she began a relationship with British television personality Chris Hughes.

At that time, Siwa was competing in the British edition of Celebrity Big Brother, where she established a close personal bond with Hughes. She was in a relationship with Australian content creator Kath Ebbs throughout the show.

During her appearance on the show, JoJo Siwa discussed her understanding of her sexuality, explaining she no longer believed the term lesbian completely described who she was. While on the show, Siwa said:

"I have always been afraid of feeling queer, like I have always said lesbian right, but I feel so queer. I am switching letters: f**k the L, I am going to the Q."

After the series concluded, Siwa and Ebbs split, and she later confirmed her relationship with Hughes.

She later informed YOU magazine that she had felt compelled to identify as a lesbian, noting that some pressure had also come from within the LGBTQ+ community itself.

Her remarks became part of a wider conversation concerning bisexuality, pansexuality, and the belief that a person's sexual orientation can be inferred solely from their current romantic partner's gender.


The internet reacts as JoJo Siwa says she doesn’t “have to be gay to be a gay icon”

Siwa's remarks prompted a wave of criticism and mixed reactions online, with some users questioning whether she should be considered a queer icon and others expressing sympathy as she continues to explore her identity. One user wrote:

"The less we ask her things, the better."

Another commented:

"Being gay doesn't make you a gay icon either."

Some users also questioned her influence; one wrote:

"I mean, good for her and no shade, but she's definitely not an "icon" of anything."

Another user was more critical:

"She’s NOT a queer icon otherwise; she has done nothing but more irreparable damage to the lesbian community."

One user reacted with a GIF, writing:

"The queer community:"

Some also pointed out that gay pop stars have existed for a long time. One user wrote:

"We’ve come a long way from her bold claims that she’s the first gay pop star the world ever saw."

Her changing descriptions of her sexuality also became a talking point. A user pointed out:

"We’ve gone through three JoJo Siwa sexuality announcements."

Another comment questioned her career and public profile. The user wrote:

"What has she ever done besides being on Dance Moms, like, actually?"

However, not all reactions were critical. One user expressed understanding of Siwa's journey, writing:

"I can't be mad she's figuring sh*t out; look at her childhood and tell me ur shocked."

Stay tuned to Soap Central for more information.

Love movies? Try our Box Office Game and Movie Grid Game to test your film knowledge and have some fun!

Edited by Zachary D. Lyngdoh