What did Red Hot Chili Peppers guitarist say about Rick Rubin? Criticisms explored as band dresses as producer 

F1 Grand Prix of Italy - Source: Getty
What did Red Hot Chili Peppers guitarist say about Rick Rubin? Criticisms explored as band dresses as producer - Source: Getty: F1 Grand Prix of Italy

Rick Rubin was inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame on November 14, 2026, and the sixty-three-year-old legendary music producer received quite the tribute. Neil Young, whose 2022 album World Record Rubin had produced, stepped up to introduce him at the ceremony. Young spoke warmly about what made Rubin special in the studio, saying that “the music is all that’s allowed in,” and that “the people that make the music are cared for because they’re recognized.”

After Rubin took the stage and left with his message that “you can’t kill rock and roll,” four fake versions of him appeared. Red Hot Chili Peppers had dressed up in masks, beards and hair styled to mirror Rubin’s trademark look, and launched into a fiery rendition of their 1991 hit, Give It Away. Frontman Anthony Kiedis capped it off, declaring “We love you, Rick Rubin” to a crowd that gave the band a standing ovation, with Rubin himself among those on their feet.

That love, however, hasn’t always gone both ways. According to a report shared by Guitar World, former RHCP guitarist Josh Klinghoffer, forty-seven, who went by the solo name Pluralone, didn’t hold back when asked about working with Rubin during his time with the band.

“Rick Rubin was way more a hindrance than a help,” said Klinghoffer.

(The views expressed here are Klinghoffer’s own, made in the context of a 2022 interview, and are not a position held by this outlet.)


Why Josh Klinghoffer believes Rick Rubin held Red Hot Chili Peppers back:

2026 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony - Inside - Source: Getty
2026 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony - Inside - Source: Getty

Before going further, Klinghoffer made something clear. He admitted that his read on all of this may be “biased” and “warped” given the circumstances, with John Frusciante having returned to the band and taken back his spot. But even with that caveat on the table, when it came to his two studio albums with the Peppers, 2011’s I’m With You and 2016’s The Getaway, his feelings weren’t exactly warm.

“I’m incredibly conflicted about my output with that band because I feel like, in both circumstances, producers got in the way of us truly making great music or a great record,” Klinghoffer told VW Music.
“I like almost all of the songs that we wrote together, but seldom did we capture them in the best way,” he added.

The Getaway had Danger Mouse behind the boards. I’m With You, on the other hand, went through Rubin, who had already helmed five previous RHCP albums before it. When it came to Rubin’s role on that record specifically, Klinghoffer had more to say.

“I will say that in the case of I’m With You, I feel Rick Rubin was way more a hindrance than a help,” he said.
“He told me once, ‘I just want to help the songs be the best they can be.’ I should’ve said, ‘Well, then get your driver to come and get you,’” he added.

He’s not alone in this. As per a report shared by Guitar World, AC/DC’s late rhythm guitarist Malcolm Young shared his take on working with Rick Rubin back in 2003, and it doesn’t read too differently. Young was looking back at the band’s 1995 album Ballbreaker, which Rubin had produced.

“When we worked with Rick there was something not quite right there,” Young said.

Young also added that:

“He’s not a real rock and roller, that’s for sure. All he worried about was the snare drum. We would never go back to him. We thought he was a phony, to be honest!”

(These views belong to Klinghoffer and the late Malcolm Young individually, shared years apart in separate interviews, and speak only to their own studio experiences.)


Black Sabbath, Slipknot and Velvet Revolver musicians open up about their complicated experiences with Rick Rubin:

OMR Festival 2024 In Hamburg - Source: Getty
OMR Festival 2024 In Hamburg - Source: Getty

According to a report shared by Far Out Magazine, part of what makes Rubin so divisive is that his style in the studio doesn’t match what most musicians expect. Rather than mapping out arrangements, he tends to work as an outside ear. Artists who come in expecting firmer direction can find themselves largely on their own.

Black Sabbath bassist Geezer Butler worked with Rubin and came away with mixed feelings. He was measured in what he shared, but the critique was present all the same. Sharing his thoughts, Butler said:

“Some of it I liked, some of it I didn’t like particularly. It was a weird experience, especially with being told to forget that you’re a heavy metal band.”

Slipknot’s Corey Taylor was notably less diplomatic. The band had worked with Rick Rubin on their third album, Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses). His read on the experience didn’t take long to deliver.

“Yeah, he kicked it on the couch, stroked his beard and nodded and then he was out,” said Taylor.

Velvet Revolver went one step further and fired Rick Rubin during the making of their debut album. The band admittedly wasn’t ready to record at the time. Rhythm guitarist Dave Kushner later described how the dynamic played out anyway.

“You just write a bunch of sh*t, you record it, he listens to it, and he goes, ‘Oh, that thing’s good – why don’t you work on that some more?’ When he thinks you’re ready, he’ll say, ‘Alright, let’s make a record’, but we were getting really impatient,” shared Kushner.

(Butler, Taylor and Kushner each speak from their own time in the studio with Rubin, and these are their personal creative assessments.)

Love movies? Try our Box Office Game and Movie Grid Game to test your film knowledge and have some fun!

Edited by Ryan D'souza