9-1-1 Season 10: Fans are 'getting really tired' of Athena's endless cycle of near-death scares

Aashna
9-1-1 Season 10 (Image via Instagram/@911onabc)
9-1-1 Season 10 (Image via Instagram/@911onabc)

The fall finale of 9-1-1 Season 10, titled Et Tu?, found Athena (Angela Bassett) in yet another life-or-death situation, after she collapsed as the end credits rolled. While ABC's firefighter procedural is known for its intense cliffhangers, fans are questioning how many more life-or-death ordeals Athena can take.

When Detective Hooks, the man who shot her in the previous season, was stabbed 19 times and found dead in prison, Athena became the primary suspect in the latest episode. During questioning, when the investigator confronted Athena's connection with an inmate and showed her a photo, she panicked and collapsed on the ground, as if having a heart attack.

With ABC's procedural going on a winter hiatus, the 9-1-1 Season 10 fall finale decided to leave things on a tense but predictable cliffhanger, with Athena's life hanging in the balance.

A Reddit user seemed tired of 9-1-1 putting Athena in a new dangerous situation in each season:

"I’m getting really tired of the constant life-or-death scenarios with Athena. She feels so different now without Bobby as well. It’s like a very distant connection with her character now."

Fans aren't buying another round of danger for Athena in 9-1-1 Season 10

For a show that thrives on high-stakes emergencies, Athena's constant battle with life-threatening situations is beginning to feel less exciting and more repetitive to fans. From a deadly space adventure to getting stranded underground during a lava explosion, a mid-air plane collision, and Bobby Nash's death, the show has put Athena through a grinder, and the 9-1-1 Season 10 fall finale was no different.

After Peter Krause's exit, Bassett is undoubtedly the most important character in 9-1-1 Season 10. In an interview with TV Fanatic, creator Tim Minear even admitted that he is a little superstitious about having an episode that doesn’t have Bassett in it. But the procedural seems to recycle the same storyline, putting Athena into different life-or-death situations.

A still from the series (Image via Instagram/@911onabc)
A still from the series (Image via Instagram/@911onabc)

A Reddit user had a strong reaction to Athena's latest health scare:

"Athena, in danger again??? I actually fell asleep while watching it live. Does Tim Minear not know how to handle character development?"

The problem isn't that Athena faces danger. After all, working in law enforcement naturally exposes her to unpredictable and potentially fatal situations. The issue is how frequently the show returns to the same narrative device to create tension around her character.

Athena's latest brush with tragedy in the 9-1-1 Season 10 fall finale feels especially repetitive, as she just spent three episodes trapped in an underground tunnel as the 118 faced a Lava Land in Los Angeles.

Another Reddit user noted:

"The ending was boring. I like Athena but her being in constant peril is too cliche."

Another user agreed:

"Athena in a life or death situation for the millionth time. Good grief."

Athena certainly remains a fan-favorite character, and her determination to get justice and her composure during difficult situations stand out. But 9-1-1 Season 10 constantly putting her in life-or-death situations has raised concerns about how the procedural plans to expand her storyline beyond her ability to miraculously survive every adversity.


Beyond the uncertainty around Athena's fate, the 9-1-1 Season 10 fall finale has set another mystery surrounding the inmate, who was likely involved in Hooks' murder.

There is only so much suspense that can be created through repeated near-death experiences before the emotional impact begins to fade. What once made viewers anxious about Athena's fate is now becoming something of an expectation.

Season 10 of 9-1-1 will return with new episodes on ABC on January 7, 2027.


For the latest scoops on your favorite TV shows and movies, follow SoapCentral.

Edited by Aashna