'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
Hold on tight, fans of true crime, because Dateline: Mystery on the Mississippi takes one of the most controversial mysteries in small-town America right, and places you into the thick of it. The show also answers its question right from the beginning: even after years of probing, two highly publicized trials, and intensely disputed forensic opinions, the official status of the Cory Lovelace case remains undecided.
What a tangled story! Dateline narrates it just like it was documented: a case that first aroused suspicion, then practically evaporated because of contradictory medical testimony, and ultimately culminated in the not-guilty verdict.
Quincy, Illinois, was thoroughly shaken even before the show came back to it with this case: in February 2006, a mother of four was found dead in the morning, and the cause of death was classified as “undetermined”. A detective reopened the case years later, and the husband was arrested for murder, but was later found not guilty.
It’s the kind of real-life mystery that viewers cannot help but be intrigued by right away. Conflicting expert testimonies, a body that was cremated, and a retrial that resulted in acquittal, the episode illustrates why this case still is a source of disputes, which no court ruling can fully solve.
The 2006 morning that sparked the Dateline investigation
A tale composed in the manner of a forensic detective starts on the 14th of February, 2006, narrating the incident when the corpse of a 38-year-old woman, Cory Cathryn Lovelace, was discovered in Quincy. The one who dialed the police was Curtis Lovelace, a husband and a former prosecutor. Cory was declared dead at the place of occurrence.
Cory had struggled for many years with her health, as was stated by CBS News and her obituary. Alcoholism, bulimia, and liver disease were reported as the main reasons for her health problems and would later become the focal points in both trials. The coroner determined her death was of "undetermined" cause.
Such a classification left the case inactive for years, as there was no criminal suspicion during that period. She was cremated shortly thereafter, a fact important to the coverage both on Dateline and on CBS because it meant that, when this case surfaced again, further forensic examination would not be possible.
Why was the case reopened years later
The case did not come back to life until the year 2013, when Detective Adam Gibson of the Quincy Police Department decided to investigate the old case files on the occasion of conducting his usual cold case reviews. He re-assessed the file, scrutinized pictures taken during the event, and was of the opinion that Cory's position, body rigidity, and death-like state were all suggestive of suffocation as a possible cause.
He was subsequently indicted by a hung jury in August 2014, after consultation with forensic experts. As Dateline indicates, this move came years after the original investigation and without any new physical evidence, relying almost entirely on photographic interpretation and expert opinion.
Dateline's breakdown of the first trial
The first trial was in 2016, and the series outlines the central theory of the prosecution that Curtis had smothered Cory and that the patterns of rigor mortis support such a notion. They said her posture and facial appearance showed she had been dead longer than Curtis claimed.
Yet Dateline also gave considerable time to the defense position, strongly supported by medical records and testimony:
- Her death could have been caused by complications in Cory's health.
- The liver was enlarged, demonstrating consistency with chronic illness.
- Symptoms described in the autopsy, according to testifying experts for the defense, indicated natural causes.
Among critical pieces of the defense that got confirmation in reporting by CBS and SJ-R, too, was testimony from the children of the Lovelaces that they, in fact, saw Cory alive during the morning of her death. This was against the timeline offered by the prosecution.
After days of deliberation, the jury did not deliver a unanimous verdict. In fact, a mistrial was declared by the judge, which, for Dateline, is more of a turning point than a conclusion.
Dateline's reporting on the second trial
A second trial was granted in 2017, and the trial venue was moved to another county because of the extensive publicity locally in hopes of having a more neutral pool. According to the show's reporting, the prosecution held fast to its previously alleged theory while the defense advanced its medical explanations even further.
As both People and SJ-R's courtroom coverage reported in detail, in the second trial, Erika Gomez, Curtis' second wife, took the stand and gave testimony. Gomez, who was married to Curtis from 2008 to 2013, built on the prosecution's accusations and alleged that her ex-husband killed his first wife. Gomez could not provide any evidence to support her claims.
After considering all the evidence, this second jury, in March 2017, found Curtis Lovelace NOT GUILTY. Dateline and other media outlets pointed out that the jury was finding reasonable doubt and not determining what killed Cory.
Dateline's approach
One reason Mystery on the Mississippi is of interest to people today is because of its strictly balanced presentation. The episode doesn't lead towards pointing out a person's guilt or innocence, but rather, it:
- Reconstructs timeline using verified testimony.
- Presents medical interpretation
- Acknowledges Cory's documented health struggles.
- Features testimony by Erika Gomez
The reporting from Dateline mirrors precisely what the court record shows: a case hinged on interpretation rather than new forensic evidence, leaving jurors and viewers weighing what could have happened, what probably did, and what was provable.
Life after the verdict
In a subsequent report by CBS, Curtis Lovelace spoke publicly about how he's rebuilding his life after being acquitted. The Dateline features those developments after the trial that are intended to show that the consequences of such a case do not end with the court proceedings.
What is more, the official cause of Cory's death has still not been established, and the show treats this mystery as the main fact of the case.
Dateline revisits the Cory Lovelace case with the same uncertainty that marked it from the start. With forensic opinions in conflict, no physical evidence beyond photographs, and a body that couldn't be reexamined, here's how Dateline pegs why this case resulted in a not-guilty verdict, not because all questions were resolved, but because the proof could never meet the burden.
Trending
The careful retelling leaves viewers with a case defined not by definitive answers but by the limits of what could be proved more than a decade after Cory's death.
Also read: Dateline: The Premonition - A complete timeline of the John Yelenic murder case, revisited
Reply
