Hallmark Media renews Sarah Drew’s Mistletoe Murders for a Season 3 - here’s everything we know so far

A still from Mistletoe Murders, featuring Sarah Drew as Emily Lane and Peter Mooney as Sam Wilner
A still from Mistletoe Murders | Image via Youtube/@Hallmark+

Mistletoe Murders will make a return with its third season, as per the announcement made by Hallmark Media. As reported by Deadline, the mystery series is scheduled to go into production towards the end of this year. During Hallmark’s ‘Countdown to Christmas’ event, the fresh episodes shall be released. The series stars Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney in the lead.

Released in 2024, the story of the series is set in Fletcher’s Grove, Upstate New York. It involves an upbeat and cordial woman named Emily Lane, who is a Yuletide vendor. But behind all the Christmas spirit, a secret is lurking.

As Emily begins looking deep into the murders taking place in the town, she joins the razor-sharp investigator Sam Wilner. But here’s the biggest twist: Emily herself has skeletons in her closet.

Keep reading to know more about the upcoming Mistletoe Murders Season 3.


Sarah Drew's Emily returns to Fletcher's Grove with Mistletoe Murders Season 3

youtube-cover

After the nail-biting ending of Season 2, the show will continue its storyline in the upcoming season. At the end of the last season, we witnessed Emily and Sam develop a romantic connection. They also decided to come clean with each other. Now, since Hallmark Media has greenlit the renewal, we can cool our heels until Mistletoe Murders Season 3 releases in the holiday season of 2026.

This is what Hallmark Media’s Head of Programming, Michelle Vicary, said about the show as well as its significant impact:

“Mistletoe Murders embodies so many of the elements viewers turn to Hallmark for: romance, community and Christmas wrapped within a cozy mystery. Over two seasons, viewer response to this series has been overwhelmingly positive and we cannot wait to bring them back to Fletcher’s Grove and to continue to reveal the backstory that has made Emily Lane one of the most enigmatic characters on television."

Vicary, in her statement, acknowledges the show’s potential as well as the strong audience fanbase it has garnered over time. She also makes a crucial point that this show is much more than just a toasty holiday tale. In fact, the story is a lot about Emily. Therefore, the upcoming season will explore more about her backstory.

The production companies involved in the project are Headspinner Productions and Lionsgate Canada. Lionsgate Television is overseeing the global sales of Mistletoe Murders.

The showrunner of the series is Ken Cuperus, who also serves as its executive producer. Joining him in producing the series, we have the President of Television at Lionsgate, Jocelyn Hamilton. Along with them, we have Michelle Melanson and the lead star, Sarah Drew herself. Hamilton expresses her excitement as the series is renewed for the next season by stating:

“Season three of Mistletoe Murders represents everything we love about working with Hallmark: a shared commitment to entertaining storytelling, beloved characters, and holiday magic that resonates with audiences year after year. We’re thrilled to continue our partnership and to keep expanding this world, delivering more of the mystery, heart, and festive charm that fans have come to expect from the franchise.”

In Mistletoe Murders Season 3, we can expect higher stakes, which will certainly skyrocket the thrill. If you have not watched the series yet, catch the two seasons on Hallmark+ in order to be up to date with the story. It has garnered a good response, with a ranking of 7.6 on IMDb and a 90% Popcornmeter score.


Stay tuned for more such stories at Soap Central!

Also read: 5 most iconic Christmas and New Year episodes from Friends

Edited by Ritika Pal