NCIS Season 5 Episode 9 “Lost & Found” cast and characters: Here’s who brought the CBS procedural series to life

A still fromm NCIS Season 5 Episode 9 “Lost & Found” (Image Via: Apple TV)
A still fromm NCIS Season 5 Episode 9 “Lost & Found” (Image Via: Apple TV)

Season 5 Episode 9, titled Lost and Found of NCIS, is about how a normal day unravels into a shocking discovery about a missing child. The episode works so well because the NCIS cast brings every moment to life with heart, humor, and tension.

So who exactly carried this story on their shoulders? Here is a full guide to every NCIS actor in this episode and how each character has shaped the mystery around the episode.

Let’s break down the episode and the faces behind this fan favorite watch.


What is Season 5 Episode 9 “Lost and Found” of NCIS about?

Season 5 Episode 9 Lost and Found of NCIS begins with a group of scout kids touring the lab, and what seems like a fun field trip suddenly turns into a case the team never expected.

A fingerprint scan reveals that one of the boys is actually an abducted child from years ago. From here, the episode shifts gears, and the whole team races to figure out who the boy really is and what happened to his father.

What makes this episode stand out is how the team reacts to the situation. You see Gibbs soften the moment a scared kid is pulled into his world. You watch Tony and Ziva argue, but still work in sync.

Abby tries her best to make the boy feel safe while doing her lab magic. McGee is torn between being a scout leader and an agent. Everyone carries a different piece of the weight, but they deliver it with just as much enthusiasm.


The cast and characters of Lost and Found

1) Leroy Jethro Gibbs, played by Mark Harmon

Gibbs is the strong center of NCIS, and in this episode, he instantly forms a bond with Carson.

Mark Harmon - Source: Getty
Mark Harmon - Source: Getty

He watches over him the way only Gibbs can, staying calm while pushing the case forward. His instincts lead the entire investigation, and he refuses to jump to conclusions about Carson’s father.

Mark Harmon is also known for: Freaky Friday & Wyatt Earp.


2) Ziva David, played by Cote de Pablo

Ziva brings her steady and sharp energy to the NCIS team. She questions every detail about Carson’s custody and never lets emotions cloud the facts.

Cote de Pablo - Paramount+ Exclusive NCIS: "Tony & Ziva" - Photocall - Source: Getty
Cote de Pablo - Paramount+ Exclusive NCIS: "Tony & Ziva" - Photocall - Source: Getty

She even tracks Brian through the woods, showing the survival skills she’s known for.

Cote de Pablo is also known for: The Dovekeepers & The Education of Max Bickford.


3) Anthony "Tony" DiNozzo Junior played by Michael Weatherly

Tony adds warmth and humor to the episode. He sees a younger version of himself in Carson, who loves movies just like him. Their scenes give the case a lighter heartbeat, even when things get tense.

Michael Weatherly - Paramount+ Exclusive NCIS: "Tony & Ziva" - Photocall - Source: Getty
Michael Weatherly - Paramount+ Exclusive NCIS: "Tony & Ziva" - Photocall - Source: Getty

Michael Weatherly is also known for: Charlie Valentine & Her Minor Thing.


4) Timothy McGee played by Sean Murray

McGee is stuck in a strange spot since Carson is part of his scout group. He handles the digital side of the case, helping the team uncover calls, records, and old background checks that reveal the truth.

Shane's Inspiration's 20th Anniversary Gala - Source: Getty
Shane's Inspiration's 20th Anniversary Gala - Source: Getty

Sean Murray is also known for: Hocus Pocus & Fall Into Darkness.


5) Abby Sciuto played by Pauley Perrette

Abby shines in the lab, teaching the scouts about her machines before everything flips. She keeps Carson distracted with games, but also processes evidence that becomes the turning point of the case.

2023 Outfest Los Angeles' - "Studio One Forever" Premiere - Source: Getty
2023 Outfest Los Angeles' - "Studio One Forever" Premiere - Source: Getty

Pauley Perrette is also known for: The Ring & Dawson's Creek.


6) Dr. Donald Ducky Mallard, played by David McCallum

Ducky appears just long enough to break down Brian’s personality through photos. His calm, thoughtful observations help the NCIS team understand what kind of man they’re searching for.

David McCallum - Source: Getty
David McCallum - Source: Getty

David McCallum is also known for: The Man from U.N.C.L.E. & The Invisible Man.


7) Director Jenny Shepard, played by Lauren Holly

Jenny steps in and takes temporary custody of Carson. Her scenes show a softer side as she reflects on the family she never had while still keeping her role as NCIS Director.

Lauren Holly is also known for: Picket Fences & Family Law.


Other stars that appear in the episode are:

8) Carson Taylor, played by Dominic Scott Kay

Carson is the heart of the episode. He’s smart, curious, and stubborn in his loyalty toward his dad. His connection with Gibbs and Tony makes the NCIS team even more protective of him.

Dominic Scott Kay is also known for: Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End & Charlotte's Web.


9) Brian Taylor, played by Chris William Martin

Brian is a survival teacher who took his son after losing a custody case. Even though he’s been painted as dangerous, the team slowly uncovers that he might not be the villain others claimed he was.

Chris William Martin is also known for: V.C. Andrews' Heaven & Heartland.


10) Navy Lt. Elaine Taylor, played by Karis Campbell

Elaine knows something is off in her husband’s past but stands by him anyway. She once hired a private investigator to get answers, yet stayed loyal, proving she was never part of any crime.

Karis Campbell is also known for: The West Wing & Boston Public.


11) Detective Marshall Collins, played by JR Bourne

Collins is a Metro detective whose impatience raises eyebrows. When evidence linked to him appears tampered with, the NCIS team starts to question whether he framed Brian years ago.

JR Bourne is also known for: Teen Wolf & Miracle Desert.


Lost and Found” works because the NCIS cast plays every emotion with honesty. Each character adds a different spark, turning a simple fingerprint finding into a story about trust, family, and truth.

This episode is a reminder that NCIS isn’t just about solving crimes. It’s about the people solving them. And in Season 5 Episode 9, this cast brings one of the show’s most memorable cases to life.


Stay tuned to SoapCentral for more.

Edited by IRMA