"No floating candles" - Fans claim the HBO Harry Potter adaptation is "ruined"

Floating candles in the latest clip | Image Via: YouTube/Harry Potter
Floating candles in the latest clip | Image Via: YouTube/Harry Potter

HBO surprisingly dropped a clip from the upcoming Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone this weekend. The one-and-a-half-minute-long clip showed a scene set after the sorting ceremony. Fans latched on to the whimsical vibe of the scene and are expressing their excitement for the HBO series on their respective social media platforms.

However, one specific social media site is singing a different tune. Skydance CEO David Ellison posted the same clip on his X (formerly Twitter) account. However, the comments section on Ellison's post has a different tone than the other sites. Some comments are a bit inaccurate as well. One such comment inaccurately said that the HBO Harry Potter adaptation had no floating candles:

"Yikes. No floating candles is a small sign that they ruined this."

Other comments have also been negative about the Harry Potter clip

Apart from the one comment above, other users had similar negative reactions to the clip. One fan had three suggestions to fix the overall look of the HBO Harry Potter show:

"1. Fix the color. 2. Ditch the Candy Crush animations. 3. Dumbledore deserves better than a synthetic Santa beard."

Another comment stated that the user preferred the visual effects from the 2001 movie:

"Looks terrible. I want to like it too. Please recast and do better. The 2001 CGI looks better."

Another comment pointed out that the show shouldn't have added the conversation between Dumbledore and McGonagall. The commentator further added that characters should look like their book counterparts, probably referring to Paapa Essiedu's casting as Snape:

"Mr. Ellison, If this is supposed to be book accurate then the showrunners should not need to change or add to the dialogue or stories presented in the books. And they absolutely should have made the characters true to their descriptions and depictions."

Several comments have been about the production team's choice to cast Essiedu. Essiedu, for his part, told Variety in October that the production team behind the series has been supportive of him playing the role previously played by Alan Rickman in the eight movies. Paapa Essiedu told Variety:

“The whole team has been so supportive of me. Obviously, my priority is the work. I wouldn’t take this job on [otherwise], but I walk into it with open eyes."

The actor continued:

"I take that mantle on with an open and full heart. I’ve also been blown away by a lot of the support and well-wishes and excitement.”

Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion. Please be advised.

Can we rely on X's opinions?

Honestly, X (formerly Twitter) is no longer a reliable site. Numerous accounts have the blue checkmark, but none of them belong to celebrities. If you want to gauge the excitement for a project, take anything said on X with a grain of salt, because the site has a lot of negativity that's not always warranted. Other than X, the overall consensus for HBO's adaptation of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone online is that it looks faithful to the books.

Whatever changes the first season makes are things alluded to in the book or that introduce characters from later books like Lucius Malfoy and Cornelius Fudge. But the overall plot of the first season follows the Philosopher’s Stone book. The official series logline alludes to following the plot of the first book:

"There is nothing special about Harry Potter - or so his Aunt Petunia tells him. But when a mysterious letter of admission to Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry arrives, it opens the door to a hidden world of magic, friendship and adventure. Yet behind Hogwarts’ enchanted walls lie dark secrets. Harry must find the courage to prove himself against the darkest wizard of all."

Did you like the new Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone clip?

Edited by Aratrika Baidya