Outlander hot take: Jamie wasn't the only reason Claire and Frank's marriage fell apart

For all the heartbreak that comes into Claire Fraser's life after her time-traveling adventure in Outlander, there is one relationship that often gets reduced to a rather straightforward explanation: her marriage to Frank Randall. Jamie and Claire's love story is often viewed as the reason behind her separation from Frank, turning what could have been a second chance at love into an inevitable separation.

But looking back at Frank and Claire's marriage in Outlander Season 1, it becomes increasingly difficult to blame Jamie for everything that went wrong. Claire's first marriage had cracks long before she ended up in the 18th century through the stones, hinting that she would have separated from Frank, regardless of her meeting Jamie. It is easy to blame Jamie for the fallout of Claire and Frank's marriage. But Claire's feelings for the Scottish warrior were undeniable because she never truly experienced passionate love with Frank, which hints that their marriage was doomed from the beginning.

*Disclaimer: This article is based on the author's opinions. Readers' discretion is advised.*

Here's why Claire and Frank's marriage was doomed from the beginning in Outlander

When Outlander first introduced Claire and Frank in the aftermath of World War II, their relationship appears to be entering a new chapter. Claire's voiceovers painted a vivid picture of her relationship with Frank. She met the historian through Uncle Lamb. The couple developed a friendship when Frank approached Claire's uncle about a point in French philosophy. As Frank's visits increased, his friendship with Claire transformed into love, and they married in 1937. Claire and Frank enjoyed post-marital bliss only for a year before the outbreak of World War II separated them.

The Outlander premiere caught Claire and Frank on their second honeymoon in Scotland. Claire agreed that she had grown distant from Frank after their time apart during the war, and this trip was their chance to re-establish their relationship. But long before Claire met Jamie in the 18th century, she had grown emotionally distant from Frank. While Claire became curious about the world, Frank was more interested in tracing his family history rather than reconnecting with his wife.

Outlander subtly hinted that while Claire and Frank wanted to reignite their love, they had grown and likely changed as individuals, which set their marriage on a doomed path, even before Jamie entered the picture.

How does Jamie fit into Claire and Frank's marriage in Outlander?

While Jamie wasn't the only reason Claire and Frank's marriage fell apart, his role cannot be dismissed. Jamie was a huge catalyst that made Claire realize her marriage to Frank was missing something. She not only fell in love with Jamie in Outlander, but also built a family and discovered a sense of belonging that was missing in her relationship with Frank.

This is not to say that Frank was to blame for the couple's failure, as he accepted Claire when she returned to the 20th century, pregnant with Jamie's child. While Frank still wanted to build a family with Claire and accepted Brianna as his own child, Claire had changed after her experiences in the past. Interestingly, while Claire struggled to reconnect with Frank after six years of war, she effortlessly slipped into her old rhythm with Jamie when they were reunited in Outlander Season 3, after 20 years.

There was a clear, stark contrast between Claire's marriage to Frank and Jamie. While Claire could have easily moved on with Frank and Brianna, presuming Jamie had died at the Battle of Culloden, she chose to stay loyal to him rather than return to Frank. This underscores that Claire's relationships were never defined by distance or time, but by the depth of her emotional connections.

Perhaps the biggest tragedy of Claire and Frank's marriage is that neither was necessarily wrong for wanting a different kind of life. While Jamie did not create the conflict, his presence made Claire realize what had always been missing from her marriage to Frank: an emotional connection she could never truly find with her first husband.

Trending

For the latest scoops on your favorite TV shows and movies, follow SoapCentral.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback