In the true-crime video podcast Criminally Obsessed, Susan Smith's prosecutor Tommy Pope reportedly recalled carefully staged conduct at the initial hearing when a South Carolina inmate pursued parole again. While explaining the footage showing the car drowning in water, Pope said,
"I hear something from the defense table. And I look over, and Susan's either writing little notes or playing tic-tac-toe or something like that with the law clerk. And she'll look over occasionally, look at it, and look back down."
Pope recalled that inside the court, Susan appeared relaxed, smiling, laughing, and seemingly enjoying the moment. After the footage was admitted into evidence and the television screens were turned toward the jury, jurors watched the footage clearly. The prosecutor recalled seeing different reactions among them, with some holding their breath, some crying, and others visibly emotional.
Continue reading more about Susan Smith's incident inside the courtroom.
Susan Smith's prosecutor recalled the 'crocodile tear' moment inside the courtroom
While having a discussion about the courtroom scene with Anne Emerson in Criminally Obsessed, Pope said when the video was presented before the jury, Susan Smith started crying from the other side of the courtroom. Based on what he observed earlier, he believed Susan's reaction was carefully staged.
The prosecutor further explained that he was convinced in his heart that Susan's display of emotion was orchestrated. Pope described it as what several people commonly refer to as 'crocodile tears,' something he said he had seen before in court proceedings. Pope revealed,
"Suddenly, from the other side of the courtroom, guess what I hear now? Susan's crying. So I know for a fact, in my heart of hearts, it was orchestrated, you know, you know, whether you call it crocodile tears, or whatever. Yeah, we've seen them before in court."
Pope further explained that one of the most frustrating situations was that he could not stop the proceedings and tell the jury what they had not witnessed earlier. He said he wished he could have pointed out Susan had been playing tic-tac-toe, laughing, and watching the video without showing any visible emotion. The prosecutor said,
"You know, the frustrating thing is your viewers probably realize this, but, you know, I'd have given anything to be able to say, 'whoa, whoa, whoa, stop, ladies and gentlemen, the jury, you should have seen her 10 minutes ago, when she was playing tic-tac-toe and laughing, and could see the video, you know, and so, so I think, oh, no, no, no, but I was trying to do the Vulcan mind meld where I laid it.'"
Pope recalled feeling concerned when the emotional display unfolded in the courtroom because the jury had not seen Susan Smith's earlier behavior. The prosecutor said he was trying to make sense of the contrast and strongly felt that the reaction was not genuine.
Follow Soap Central for more updates on Criminally Obsessed.