Pluribus: How The Others use celebrity culture through John Cena

John Cena in Pluribus Episode 6 delivers one of television's strangest moments this year. The wrestling icon appears not as himself, but as a hollow version controlled by The Others. His mission? To explain why the alien hivemind has been consuming human remains. Viewers watching "HDP" likely did a double-take when the Peacemaker star appeared on screen. But this isn't a typical celebrity cameo. Vince Gilligan chose John Cena in Pluribus for a very specific reason.

The appearance raises uncomfortable questions about manipulation and control. What happens when someone famous loses everything that made them special? Can The Others truly claim benevolence while using recognizable faces to push their agenda? This cameo does more than shock audiences. It exposes how celebrity influence works even in a post-invasion world. The scene feels unsettling because something essential is missing. Where is the charisma? Where is the spark that made Cena a star? Gone. Replaced by the same pleasant emptiness every Other displays.

---

Why did The Others choose a celebrity spokesperson in Pluribus?

The decision to use John Cena in Pluribus wasn't random. The Others understand human psychology better than they admit. They know people respond to familiar faces. Carol Sturka has just discovered vats of human bodies being processed into drinks. She's horrified and angry. So, The Others send her a video featuring someone the world recognizes. Someone non-threatening. Someone who has sold everything from action figures to insurance policies.

Gilligan himself acknowledged the strategy behind casting Cena. He told Men's Health they wanted someone interesting to deliver this disturbing message. The choice reveals sophisticated manipulation.

The Others claim they want humans to live freely. Yet they deploy celebrity culture as a tool for control. If a famous person says it, people listen. If a beloved figure explains it, the message goes down easier. Even Cena seemed confused by his own dialogue, reportedly saying he couldn't wait to understand what he'd just recorded.

Also See: School Spirits Season 3 is officially returning to Paramount+ early next year - here's when

---

What does this cameo reveal about life under The Others?

John Cena in Pluribus shows audiences the cost of assimilation. He speaks clearly and explains the situation calmly. But something vital is absent. The energy that made him entertaining has vanished. He's been reduced to a friendly automaton delivering corporate talking points. This reflects the larger question the show keeps asking viewers. Is equality worth losing individuality?

The Others have eliminated poverty and suffering. Everyone shares the same consciousness now. No more competition. No more jealousy or pride. But watching John Cena in Pluribus operate without his signature personality feels deeply wrong. The episode also features a poker game among The Others that proves monotonous without human players. Once the camera stops rolling, Cena likely returns to that same blank existence.

His appearance suggests that The Others keep certain people on standby for public relations purposes. They're not using him for entertainment or art. They're using him to pacify immune humans like Carol.

Also See: “They surprised me”: Pluribus star Rhea Seehorn reveals she want expecting the Better Call Saul cameo

---

How does this fit into the show's bigger themes?

The use of John Cena in Pluribus connects to ongoing debates between characters like Carol and Koumba Diabaté. Diabaté believes The Others have improved the world. Carol sees the manipulation and refuses to accept their control. Both have valid points. The cameo adds weight to Carol's perspective. If The Others truly respected human autonomy, why manufacture consent through celebrity endorsements?

This scene parallels an earlier moment when The Others used Manousos' mother to emotionally influence him. They claim to be altruistic but practice strategic manipulation.

John Cena's appearance on the show forces audiences to examine their own relationship with celebrity culture. Viewers trust famous faces to sell them products, ideas, and lifestyles. The Others simply adapted the existing system to their own purposes. The cameo works because it holds up a mirror to how society already functions.

Also See: 5 Rhea Seehorn TV shows and movies to watch if you like her in Pluribus

John Cena in Pluribus proves the show excels at making audiences question everything they watch.