Homicide: New York is a documentary miniseries brought to you by Dick Wolf, whose credits include several police procedurals. It premiered on Netflix on March 20, 2024, and a second season was released on March 25, 2026. Here's the official synopsis as per IMDb:
Documentary series focusing on detectives and prosecutors as they revisit their most challenging homicide cases in the cities of New York and Los Angeles, California.
Both seasons chronicle real-life crime cases. The second season of Homicide: New York revolves around the disappearance of Joey Comunale.
The case behind Homicide: New York Season 2
Homicide: New York, Season 2, talks about cases from the perspective of NYPD detectives. The second episode, titled Party Monster, focuses on the disappearance of Joey Comunale, a Connecticut native who graduated from Hofstra University.
Joey went to Manhattan, New York, on November 12, 2016, for a night out with his friends James Rackover and Lawrence Dilione.
Joey was also accompanied by some women he had met that night. Some CCTV cameras captured him entering an apartment building before leaving for the party. It was the Sutton Place apartment where Rackover was living. Later, Joey was seen going back to the building with Dilione.
Homicide: New York showcases the women who were with Joey and were questioned by the police officers. They said that they last saw him when he put them in a taxi, assuming he was returning to the party.
However, a guy named Larry Dilione stated that Joey left at the same time. The cops also questioned Max Gemma, who was at the nightclub. He said that he slept early and wasn't aware of anything. The cops continued their investigation, and every angle was explored. Everyone involved with Joey was questioned. Eventually, it was revealed that Joey was stabbed to death inside the apartment.
The killer put his body inside the car boot. The police found the badly burnt corpse in a New Jersey shallow grave. The medical examiner attributed multiple stab wounds as the cause of death.
James Rackover revealed that he hosted a party at his home, attended by Dilione and several women. He also saw a man he did not know at the party. Dilione eventually confessed to killing Joey and burying him in New Jersey.
Dilione took the police to the site where they buried the body. The police dog traced it to the trunk of Rackover's vehicle. Dilione revealed that he got into an argument with Joey over something, and the matter escalated. The two got into a fight, and Dilione beat Joey mercilessly. He was stabbed 15 times in his chest.
Rackover was given a 28-year prison sentence with charges of second-degree murder in 2018. Dilione pleaded guilty to manslaughter in January 2019 and got a 23-year prison sentence. Gemma received a six-month sentence after pleading guilty to hindering the prosecution. He was released in August 2019.
Homicide: New York is streaming on Netflix.
Stay tuned to Soap Central for more such stories.